English 
More Real than the Video: How to Leverage TikTok Comment Replies to Gain Insights into User Behavior?
In the previous article, we discussed how to use Python crawlers or the LuckData TikTok API to extract comment replies from specific TikTok posts ( How to Retrieve Replies to a Specific TikTok Comment ID ) . After successfully obtaining this data, many people may ask an important question:
What value do these comment replies offer? What can we do with them?
In fact, the comment reply section on TikTok often reflects users' emotions and behaviors more accurately than the videos themselves. It’s the crossroads of community interaction and an important window into audience feedback. This article will break down seven key use cases for TikTok comment replies and help you extract valuable insights from these "secondary interactions."
Why Analyze Comment Replies?
Most analyses tend to focus on the primary comments (i.e., comments directly on the video), but the nature of the primary comments and replies differs significantly:
Primary comments often present one-way opinions.
Replies, however, represent interactions between users, where opinions are exchanged and debated.
TikTok’s algorithm takes user interaction into account, and comment replies play a crucial role in this.
In short: primary comments help us understand "individual thoughts," while replies give us insight into "group dynamics and consensus-building processes."
Seven Key Use Cases of TikTok Comment Replies
1. The First Site for User Feedback
Many users don’t directly comment on a video but instead express their opinions through replies to others. For example:
Primary comment: This phone looks great.
Reply 1: I’ve been using it for two weeks, and it overheats.
Reply 2: The system crashes all the time, don’t be fooled by the looks.
These replies are often more reflective of real user experiences, making them ideal for uncovering potential issues or pain points with a product.
Applicable Use Case: Brand Monitoring, Product Reviews, Customer Complaint Detection
2. Tracking Public Sentiment Trends and Emotions
The initial replies to a trending video may be mostly positive, but over time, negative emotions may start to surface. For example:
At first, replies may be mostly praise and humor.
A few hours later, critical and skeptical comments start appearing.
As time goes on, negative sentiment begins to dominate.
By analyzing these time-based emotional shifts, we can predict how public sentiment might evolve.
Applicable Use Case: Public Relations Risk Management, Trend Forecasting
3. Social Interaction and Influence Structure Analysis
There are often chains of replies that form debates, agreements, and discussions between users. By analyzing who replies to whom and the frequency of interaction, you can:
Identify key community influencers.
Analyze how influence spreads.
Build a network map of interactions.
Applicable Use Case: Social Health Analysis, KOL Discovery, Social Network Analysis
4. Content Creation Inspiration
Many TikTok creators extract feedback from comment replies to guide the creation of their next videos. For example:
Primary comment: This challenge is too easy.
Reply: Try doing it in the dark.
The creator then makes a "Dark Room Challenge" video that goes viral.
Replies are not only feedback—they’re also a source of creative inspiration.
Applicable Use Case: Creative Iteration, Interactive Content Design
5. Detecting Opinion Divides and Conflicting Viewpoints
Replies often feature opposing viewpoints, and the tension between these perspectives can signal a controversial issue. For example:
Primary comment: This song made me cry.
Reply A: It’s not the original artist’s talent; it’s the editing that’s impressive.
Reply B: This song is a rip-off, do you even know music?
These clashes in viewpoints are key to understanding the polarization of public opinion.
Applicable Use Case: Community Risk Monitoring, Opinion Segmentation, Disputed Topic Evaluation
6. Collecting Product or Service Pain Points
Replies to product or unboxing videos can quickly reveal what users care about the most. For example:
Which features are most likely to break.
Which use cases are most prone to failure.
Are there complaints about packaging, logistics, or after-sales service?
This data directly informs product optimization and customer service strategies.
Applicable Use Case: Product Design Improvement, After-Sales Process Optimization
7. Corpus Data Collection and AI Model Training
For natural language processing (NLP) applications, TikTok comment replies are highly valuable unstructured data. This can be used for:
Training sentiment analysis models.
Automatic dialogue generation.
Topic modeling and keyword extraction.
Character tagging and behavioral classification.
Applicable Use Case: Chatbots, Sentiment Recognition Systems, Automatic Summary Tools
What’s the Difference Between Primary Comments and Replies?
Analysis Aspect | Primary Comments | Comment Replies |
|---|---|---|
Audience | Directed to the video or creator | Directed to other users |
Expression Style | One-way opinion | Two-way interaction and discussion |
Visibility | High (sorted by popularity) | Medium (needs to be expanded) |
Content Focus | Initiating topics, attracting attention | Expanding viewpoints, triggering discussions |
Interaction Value | Highlighting the topic | Expanding viewpoints, exchanging positions |
How to Combine Analytical Tools for Deeper Insights?
Below are some common data analysis tools and their application directions:
Tool | Application Analysis Focus |
|---|---|
Excel / Google Sheets | Keyword frequency, simple categorization, and statistics |
Power BI / Tableau | Emotional trend visualization, timeline interaction charts |
Python (with NLP libraries) | Sentiment classification, topic modeling, dialogue tree reconstruction |
ChatGPT / LLM Models | Automatic summarization, content clustering, interaction simulation |
Conclusion and Practical Recommendations
TikTok videos are the attention-grabbing facade, while comment replies represent the "real voice" of community interactions. By leveraging these replies, you can gain insights into:
Public reactions to brands or public events.
Refining content strategy for higher engagement.
Improving product design and user experience.
Providing authentic language data for AI model training.
I recommend starting with these three steps:
Choose a trending video, extract primary comments and their replies using a crawler or API.
Select one of the seven use cases above and apply it in practice.
Import the data into analytical tools and try sentiment or viewpoint modeling.
By understanding and harnessing the value of TikTok comment replies, you can gain a deeper understanding of user behavior and community interaction patterns, which will lead to more informed decision-making for your research, operations, or product.
